self-administration - Solutions for Workers' Compensation and Liability Settlements

Sandy Simpson

08/Jan/2024

It is getting close to that time of year when mailboxes begin to receive W-2 statements and 1099-INT statements. If an injured individual has either a Self-Administered Medicare Set-Aside (MSA) account or a Professionally-Administered MSA account, the individual will be sent a 1099-INT by January 31^st and a copy will be filed with the IRS. The 1099-INT shows interest earned in the account during the previous tax year.

Liability and Workers Compensations cases should follow the Workers Compensation Medicare Set-Aside (WCMSA)Reference Guide, until CMS publishes a Liability Medicare Set-Aside (LMSA) Reference Guide. Until then, the WCMSA Reference Guide should be considered a single point of reference for Liability and Workers Compensation cases. To download the WCMSA Reference Guide Version 3.8, Dated November 14, 2022, click here.

What the WCMSA Reference Guide states:

MSA funds must be placed in an interest-bearing account that is separate from the individual’s personal savings and checking accounts.
The interest must be deposited into the MSA account to be used for MSA-covered expenses.
You can use the MSA account to pay for the income tax on the interest income.

For further clarification regarding how the individual can pay for the taxes from the interest incomed earned in their account, refer to the CMS Memo Dated July 11, 2005, Subject: Medicare Secondary Payer (MPS) – Workers’ Compensation (WC) Additional Frequency Asked Questions.

“Q6. Treatment of Taxable Interest Income Earned on a WCMSA – If I receive a Form 1099-INT for the interest income earned on my WCMSA account, may I charge the income tax on that amount against the WCMSA?

A6. Assuming that there is adequate documentation for the amount of incremental tax that the claimant must pay for the interest earned on this set-aside account, the claimant or his/her administrator may withdraw an amount equal to the additional tax as a “cost that is directly related to the account” to cover the additional tax liability. Such documentation should be submitted along with the annual accounting.”

How Medivest Handles the 1099-INT:

Medivest will advise the Member to prepare his/her tax return two ways to determine the increased income tax burden, if any:

Include the MSA interest income in the income tax return
Exclude the MSA interest income in the income tax return

In other words, if the Member must pay the IRS an increased income tax amount as a result of the interest earned from their MSA account, the additional income tax burden can be paid from the MSA account. This is considered a cost associated with having the MSA account and CMS allows this expense to be paid from the MSA account. Once a year, Medivest will send CMS an attestation for every applicable professionally-administered MSA account. Any MSA reimbursement of the additional income tax burden will be included in this attestation.

Answers to Common Questions

Question 1. If I am taxed on the earned interest, why can’t I have it?

Answer 1. CMS’ guidelines state that Medicare Set-Aside funds place must be placed into an interest-bearing account and are to be used for covered medical expenses.

Question 2. Why do I have to report the earned interest to the IRS?

Answer 2. Per IRS guidelines, all interest income is taxable, unless specifically excluded.

Question 3. Isn’t my injury settlement tax-exempt?

Answer 3. Any compensation you receive from a settlement because of physical injuries or sickness is not taxable. However, the interest earned after the settlement occurs is taxable.

Best Practices

Medivest’s highly trained representatives can help you figure out if Medicare may have an interest in your settlement. We assist all settling parties to navigate the MSP complexities and provide you with cost-saving strategies for your settlement. For questions about your account or setting up a new professional administration account please contact us here.

Sandy Simpson

20/Dec/2023

You have settled your injury case and have decided to self-administer your Medicare set-aside (MSA) arrangement. Whether you are just beginning to embark on this journey or if you have been self-administering your account for a while and need a refresher, here are a few tips you should know. These tips can help you navigate through this complicated process. They will ensure that you won’t jeopardize your Medicare benefits, help you preserve your MSA funds so they will be there when you need them the most, and will help you prepare to administer your MSA throughout 2024 and beyond.

Helpful Self-Administration Tips:

Set Up your MSA Correctly

Know how your Medicare Set-Aside account will be funded. There are two ways to fund MSA account either with a lump-sum payment or a structured annuity. If your settlement says that it will be funded as a lump sum, one check will be issued. Or, if your settlement says that it will be funded with a structured annuity, then an initial deposit is made to establish the account, followed by annual deposits.
Open a separate bank account to deposit your MSA funds. Do not co-mingle your MSA funds with your personal funds.
Deposit your MSA funds into an interest-bearing bank account, insured by FDIC.
It is recommended to find a bank that does not charge fees when you have a low balance and preferably to find an account that you could write checks on.

Learn the Process and Develop Good Habits Now

Keep your settlement paperwork in a safe place.
Know your date of settlement. Any expense that is injury related, Medicare covered, and has occurred after the date of settlement can be paid out of your Self-Administered Medicare Set-Aside account.
Only use the MSA funds from your account to pay for Medicare covered medical treatment and prescription costs related to your injury, even if you are not yet enrolled in Medicare.
Keep accurate records of the expenses you’ve paid out of your account. You will not submit these records annually, but Medicare may request these records as proof that you are using the account correctly.
- Transaction date
- Check number (if any, or transaction number if present)
- “Payable to” or health care provider name
- Date of service
- Description (procedure, service, or item received; deposit; interest; other allowable expense)
- Amount paid
- Any deposit amount
- Account balance
- Keep itemized receipts
- Banks statements
- Tax records
You will need to send an annual attestation form every year to Medicare, no later than 30 days after the anniversary date of your Workers Compensation settlement regarding funds remaining in the account after expenses have been paid.

Know What Expenses Your MSA Covers

MSA account can be used to pay for the following:
- Cost of copying documents
- Mailing fees/postage
- Any banking fees related to the account
- Income tax on interest income from the account

You may not use the MSA account to pay for:

- Fees for trustees, custodians, or other professionals hired to help administer the account
- Expenses for administration of the MSA (other than those listed above)
- Attorney costs for establishing the MSA
- Medicare premiums, co-payments and deductibles

To learn what expenses are considered Medicare covered. Get the free annual publication called Medicare & You from your Social Security office, or at: https://www.medicare.gov/medicare-and-you/medicare-and-you.html

What to Do When Your MSA is Exhausted or Depleted

If you are a Medicare beneficiary and your funds have been depleted, you can forward your bills to Medicare for payment as long as the expense is Medicare covered and injury related.
If you are not Medicare covered and your funds have been depleted, you will need to coordinate benefits with your other health insurance providers or pay out of pocket.
When your account is permanently exhausted or depleted, which means there is no money left in the account and there will be no future deposits, you will need to submit within 60 days of the date your account is depleted a final attestation letter stating the account is ‘completely exhausted’.
Notify Medicare’s Benefits Coordination & Recovery Center (BCRC) if death has occurred before the WCMSA is permanently exhausted.
If you lose your Medicare entitlement, you are not entitled to release the MSA funds.

What Happens it Self-Administering is Too Difficult?

If learning how to self-administer your MSA on your own is too difficult to navigate, contact Medivest to learn more about our Self-Administration Kit with assistance. Or, if you’re interested in a more hands-off solution, Medivest Professional Administration Services can remove potential risks and the cumbersome tasks associated with administrating your Medicare Set-Aside funds, and in most cases can even stretch the lifespan of a MSA. Please call us at 877.725.2467 or reach out to us here.

Sandy Simpson

06/Feb/2023

When an individual has a Medicare Set-Aside (MSA) account, they have the option to either self-administer the funds or have them professionally administered. If self-administration is chosen, it can be a difficult and trying task to comply with the CMS’ rules; opening a MSA checking account, learning what type of expenses can be paid and cannot be paid out, coordinating health insurance benefits, keeping accurate records, and when to send reporting to CMS. This blog will discuss what you need to know if you choose Self-Administration, and if self-administering your MSA is the right choice for you.

What is Self-Administration?

Self-administration is the process of managing the medical portion of your settlement, compromise and release, judgment, award or other payment/arrangement (“Settlement”) arising from an incident on the job and/or due to the negligence of another party. After a settlement, the individual is responsible for paying the medical claims following the process and guidelines set forth by the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services until the funds have been permanently depleted.

What is Professional Administration?

Professional administration is the practice of using a qualified third party to oversee and manage funds for future medical expenses following a liability or Workers’ Compensation settlement. Though not required, Medicare strongly suggests the professional administration of a MSA. However, for those who choose self-administration, the individual is still responsible for using their MSA account to pay for injury-related and Medicare covered expenses in accordance with the Medicare Secondary Payer (MSP) Statute. The MSP provisions protect Medicare Trust Funds by ensuring that Medicare does not pay for items and services that certain health insurance or coverage, such as a MSA account, is primarily responsible for paying.

Two Ways to Fund Your MSA Account

Before the settlement has occurred, the settling parties will discuss the ways a MSA account can be funded. Typically, there are two options:

Lump-Sum – a single lump sum payment to fund your MSA account.
Structured Settlement Annuity Funding – an initial deposit to fund your account and smaller annual deposits in the following years. The initial deposit covers the first two years of annual funding for treatments plus any cost for proposed first surgeries. If the MSA funds are not spent down in a given year, the funds must remain in the account and carry forward into the next year.

Establishing a Self-Administration Bank Account

Below is a list of CMS’ requirements regarding opening up a separate bank account for the MSA funds.

Deposit MSA funds into its own account, separate from any other accounts you may have
The account must earn interest and the interest must stay in the account
The account should be insured by Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (FDIC)
Choose a bank or an account that does not charge fees if you have a low balance
Select an account that allows you to write checks

Know What Is Covered

It is important to recognize that not every medical bill or service can be paid out of the MSA account. For individuals self-administering their account, it is highly important to be aware of qualified expenses. Below is a partial list of the expenses that can and cannot be paid out of the account:

Expenses That Can Be Paid

Funds can only be used to pay for future care that is Medicare covered and related to your injury.
Cost of copying documents
Mailing fees/postage
Any banking fees related to the account
Paying income tax on the interest income earned in the account*

*Note – The MSA funds are not considered taxable income, but the interest earned is taxable. Each year your bank will issue an IRS 1099-INT form for the interest earned in the account.

Expenses That Cannot Be Paid

Fees for trustees, custodians, or other professionals hired to help administer the account
Expenses for administration of the MSA other than those listed above
Attorney costs for establishing the MSA
Cannot use to purchase a Medicare supplemental insurance policy or a Medigap policy
Medicare premiums, co-payments, and deductibles
Acupuncture
Routine dental care
Eyeglasses
Hearing aides

For a more extensive list of what Medicare will pay, click here to obtain a copy of the free handbook “Medicare & You”.

Keep Accurate Records of All Transactions

Bank statements, receipts, and tax records should all be kept and recorded. Self-administering parties will not need to submit these records annually, but Medicare may request them as proof that the account is being used correctly. It is also recommended that settlement documents showing the date the case was settled, diagnosed injury, and date of injury are also kept. Consider keeping accurate records for each transaction such as:

Transaction date
Check number
“Payable to” or provider’s name
Date of service
Description – procedure, service or item received, deposit, interest, other allowable expenses
Amount paid
Deposit amount
Account balance
Interest earned

What is Coordination of Benefits for a MSA?

The MSP program is in place to ensure that Medicare is aware of situations where it should not be the primary payer of claims. Sometimes a Medicare beneficiary with a MSA account, public benefits, and other health insurance; the Coordination of Benefits (COB) rule decides which entity should pay first on a claim. In certain situations, if Medicare has paid a claim by mistake, CMS will take action to receive the mistaken Medicare payment.

What is the MSA Attestation?

If the MSA proposal was approved, CMS requires the attestation form to be signed, attesting that the injured party has used the account correctly and to report the amounts spent. If Medicare is satisfied that the right amount of money has been spent appropriately, Medicare will pay for future treatments for this work injury. Below is the information found on the attestation form.

Total spent for medical services
Total spent for prescription drugs
Grand total of expenditures
Total of interest income the account earned if any
Balance of MSA account at the end of the calendar year

Annual Attestation or Expenditure Letters Reporting

CMS’ Benefit Coordination & Records Center (BCRC) is responsible for monitoring and receiving the submitted attestations forms. The attestation informs Medicare that they are now primary payer when your funds have exhausted. Note, once the account funds are exhausted you must continue to pay your Medicare monthly premiums, co-pays, and deductibles in order for Medicare to pay your claims. CMS has the right to demand and receive a complete accounting of payments made from the account at its discretion. The following only applies if the MSA proposal has been approved by CMS.

Annual Attestations must be submitted every year, no later than 30 days after the end of each reporting period (beginning one year from the date of establishment of the MSA account). Annual attestations should continue through final exhaustion of the account.
Temporary Exhaustion occurs when the MSA account funds have exhausted before the next annuity has been deposited into the account.
Final Depletion or Permanent Exhaustion is where the MSA account has no money left and no future deposits of funds are expected.
Death Occurs / Inheritance before the MSA account is permanently exhausted you will need to notify the BCRC of death. This may require the MSA account to stay open for some time to pay outstanding claims.
Completely Exhausted within 60 days of the date the MSA account is depleted, send the BCRC a final attestation that the account is ‘Completely Exhausted”.
Loses Medicare Entitlement
Re-Establishes Medicare Entitlement

How to Submit Your Attestation to CMS’ BCRC

Electronical Attestation is a Medicare web portal that allows submission of either yearly or final attestations electronically. For more information about how to submit an attestation electronically, please see the MSAP User Guide.
Mail-in Submission / Paper Copy

MSA Proposal/Final Settlement
PO Box 138899
Oklahoma City, OK 73113-8899

Call BCRC

855-798-2627 or TTY/TDD
855-787-2627 for the hearing and speech impaired
Opened: Monday – Friday, from 8am – 8pm | Eastern Time

Medivest’s Solutions

If handling a Self-Administrated account becomes too difficult of a task, Medivest can help. We provide the following options that may reduce the burden of keeping track of the details:

1. Switch to Medivest’s Professional Administration Service

For over 25 years, Medivest has been helping clients navigate the complexities of the MSP and protecting their Medicare benefits. Our services guarantee the most comprehensive and cost-effective professional administration program available and provides:

Streamlined reporting and compliance
Savings on treatment, equipment, and pharmaceuticals
Expert support and service

2. Purchase Medivest’s Self-Administration Kit

Medivest offers a Self-Administration Kit that equips individuals who opt to manage their own Worker’ Compensation or Liability settlement with many of the tools and services available to Professionally Administers settlements. The Medivest Self-Administration Kit has been designed to give the individual the flexibility in determining just how “hands-on” they wish to be in managing their medical funds, while providing to the settling parties the piece of mind that comes from knowing due diligence has been considered. Below are the services that are included Medivest’s Self-Administration Kit Services:

Detailed Booklet
Unlimited Phone
Medical Bill Review
Pharmacy and Durable Medical & Equipment (DME) Discounts

For additional information regarding Medivest’s Professional Administration Services or Self-Administration Kits or to get started with one of these options today call us at 877.725.2467 or contact us here.

Sandy Simpson

20/Nov/2019

Are you self-administering your Medicare Set-Aside (MSA) funds or do you have a client doing so? If so, you are not alone. According to the National Council on Compensation Insurance, Inc. (NCCI) recently published a research brief updating its 2014 study on Workers’ Compensation MSAs (WCMSAs) and WCMSA reviews and reported that, between 2010 and 2015, approximately ninety-eight percent (98%) of the Workers’ Compensation cases included in the over 10,000 case sample, settled with the injured worker choosing to self-administer their MSA funds. Due to the large percentage of injured workers opting to self-administer, the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) published a free downloadable, 31-page “Self-Administration Toolkit”, now in Version 1.3 which was updated on October 10, 2019.

If you’re a Claimant/Applicant/Petitioner’s attorney settling a WC case and your client is considering self-administration, below are a couple of blogs you may consider reading before deciding if self-administration is the best option.

CMS simply states that a competent administrator must be chosen to administer the MSA funds. The key word is competent, and it is the responsibility of the settling parties to deem whether the injured person is sufficiently competent to self-administer an MSA account. Below are a couple of scenarios regarding options for administration of MSA funds.

Injured Person Self-Administers his/her MSA Funds – The injured person handles his/her own MSA funds and assumes responsibility for handling the MSA funds per CMS’ guidelines for Medicare Secondary Payer (MSP) compliance.
Engage a Professional Administrator – Engage a third-party professional administration company to administer the MSA funds, coordinate all aspects of billing, complete annual reporting to Medicare as needed, maintain accounting records, etc. The Administrator assumes responsibility for handling the funds per CMS’s guidelines for compliance. Per CMS’s guidelines, fees for professional administration cannot be deducted out of the corpus of the MSA funds.
Engage A Trustee – Engage a person or professional entity (like a bank or trust company) who manages property or assets that have been placed in a Trust (i.e. a Special Needs Trust (SNT)). Per CMS’s guidelines, fees for a trustee cannot be deducted out of the corpus of the MSA funds.
Appointed Guardian or Conservator – An individual that has been determined to be mentally or physically incapacitated by a court of law, or when a minor is in need of an adult to manage his/her property, a guardian or conservator may be appointed.

Post Settlement Tips for Self-Administration

Per CMS’ guidelines, do not co-mingle MSA funds with personal funds. Place the MSA funds into a separate, interest bearing, FDIC insured account.
Keep pertinent documents regarding the settlement in a safe place. You may need to refer to these documents for paying claims, if applicable. Examples include: o Executed Settlement
o Power of Attorney
o Conservator or Guardianship appointment
o Trust documents
o MSA Allocation Report / Life Care Plan / Medical Cost Projection Report
or a report that was prepared and used in the settlement to determine
and allocate the total future Medicare Set-Aside (MSA) funds.
o CMS Approval Letter, applicable if the MSA was submitted to CMS for review
o Accurate annual accounting, post settlement
o Keep track of all post settlement expenses, receipts paid and copies of bills
o Annual attestation letters, post settlement (these can now be submitted electronically)
o Any correspondence from CMS, post settlement
Document Retention – How long should you keep settlement documents, CMS letters, etc? These documents you may want to keep for the life of your account. How long should you keep payments of medical bills, annual accounting, and yearly attestations? State laws generally govern how long medical records are to be retained. However, the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act of 1996’s (HIPAA) administrative simplification rules require a covered entity, such as a physician billing Medicare, to retain required documentation for six years from the date of its creation or the date when it last was in effect, whichever is later. https://www.cms.gov/Outreach-and-Education/Medicare-Learning-Network-MLN/MLNMattersArticles/downloads/SE1022.pdf
What type of MSA funding arrangement was decided at the time of settlement? There are two types of MSA funding arrangements.
1. Lump Sum Funding – After settlement, a check for a one-time payment representing all future medical expenses that are injury related and Medicare allowable is issued.
2. Structured Annuity Funding – A combination of a check for the initial deposit or seed money used to fund the MSA. The amount of the seed deposit typically includes the first surgical procedure or replacement and the equivalent of two years of annual funds along with the yearly annuity payment beginning on the 1-year anniversary of settlement. Note: Medicare recognizes a structured settlement annuity as a viable method of funding MSAs. Medicare will become the primary payer of injury-related medical expenses, once documentation is provided showing the MSA funds were spent appropriately and there is no other available primary coverage to pay for injury-related Medicare covered medical expenses – until the next upcoming annuity payment has been deposited into the MSA account. For topics unique to Structured WCMSA Accounts, please refer to this link.
Before the injured person’s case settles, the WC claims adjuster typically will have paid for medical treatments and prescription medication that were related to the injury. After settlement occurs, the MSA funds should be used to pay injury-related and Medicare allowable expenses from the settlement date forward until exhausted.
If you are a Medicare beneficiary, you will need to continue to pay Medicare premiums, co-payments, and deductible amounts. Medicare updates its plans, premium costs, and coverage on a yearly basis. Each year, Medicare publishes a free downloadable handbook called “Medicare and You”.
If the injured person is Medicare eligible, he/she can add coverage to or change his/her plan during Medicare’s Open Enrollment period. The Open Enrollment period would not have an impact on their MSA Funds that they are currently self-administering. Every year, Medicare’s Open Enrollment period begins October 15th and ends December 7th for most Medicare plans. For Medicare Advantage plans, open enrollment runs from January 1st through February 14th. Medicare has designed a Medicare Plan Finder which it describes as a convenient way to compare coverage options, shop for plans, and feel confident about the coverage choices Medicare enrollees make. It also lets Medicare beneficiaries build and track their drug list to determine the best Part D (prescription drug) plan that meets their medical needs, including the display of lower-cost generic alternatives. Some details regarding Medicare Advantage Plans can be reviewed by clicking this link so you can compare covered benefits.
Medicare-Certified Providers – When choosing providers to receive care, consideration should be given whether the providers will be able to bill Medicare in the event MSA funds have either temporarily or permanently exhausted (depleted), or in the event a Medicare beneficiary may need Medicare covered treatment that is not injury related. If a provider cannot file claims to Medicare, the Medicare beneficiary may be billed for services in select circumstances. To locate providers that are Medicare-certified, please click here.
Reimbursement of Medicare Conditional Payments before and after settlement. If Medicare pays for care related to your injury, it may be doing so on the condition that Medicare will later be reimbursed for such payments. More information about Medicare’s right to recovery may be found here.
At the end of each year, interest earned on MSA funds will need to be identified as interest income generated from the MSA account for the prior tax year. Under CMS’ guidelines, the interest earned is to be deposited and remain in the MSA account to pay only for Medicare allowable expenses related to the injury, or used for other allowable purposes, such as to cover banking fees related to the account, mailing/postage fees related to the account, miscellaneous related document copying charges, and income tax on interest income from the MSA account.

Mismanaged MSA Funds

During the pre-settlement phase, the pricing of medical items and services for most MSA allocation reports are prepared using Workers’ Compensation state fee schedules for the state where the injury occurs. For liability cases, those medical items and services are priced at the Usual and Customary rate for the geographic region. For both WC and liability cases, prescription drug expenses are typically priced at Average Wholesale Pricing (AWP). Injured parties might not subscribe to or otherwise access the AWP pricing rates or state fee schedule rates and could end up paying for medical treatment or prescriptions drugs at amounts higher than they should.
When the injured person mistakenly pays for a non-Medicare allowable expense out of the MSA account, Medicare reserves the right to deny all injury-related Medicare covered claims until the MSA funds have been replenished or the injured worker can demonstrate appropriate usage equal to the full amount of the MSA.
If a provider mistakenly sends the bill to Medicare when it should have been paid out of a MSA account, the claim may be denied by Medicare and this could lead to CMS initiating an audit of the MSA funds.
Medicare may accidentally pay for an injury-related claim when it should have been paid out of the MSA account. The injured person may end up being billed or charged for the Medicare copay, coinsurance, or deductible amount, and later, still have to reimburse Medicare from the MSA funds.

When considering all the factors described above, doesn’t it make sense to strongly consider the use of a professional administrator? Also, The Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) published in the WCMSA Reference Guide, that professional administration is highly recommended.

Simply put, Professional Administration makes sense. If you are an attorney or an injured person who has questions regarding switching from self-administration to professional administration, Medivest is here to answer any questions you may have.

Natt Reifler, Esq., CMSP, VP of MSP Compliance

18/Apr/2018

Injured Medicare beneficiaries or those with a reasonable expectation of becoming enrolled in Medicare within 30 months of settlement (claimants) have a legal responsibility under the Medicare Secondary Payer statute enacted in 1980 (MSP)[1], to not prematurely bill Medicare for injury-related otherwise Medicare allowable, medical expenses (future medicals). Because many claimants and even their attorneys still don’t know the MSP law exists or how to comply with it, many settlements for claimants don’t properly consider and protect Medicare’s interests as a secondary payer for future medicals. Medicare Set-Aside (MSA) compliance programs consider Medicare’s MSP interests and implement actions to protect those interests. MSP compliance companies rely heavily on two valuable tools that work best in conjunction to achieve MSP compliance goals; a MSA allocation report (also known as a Set-Aside arrangement) estimating future medicals, and administration of MSA funds, with spending restricted to applicable future medicals. If administration of MSA settlement funds is handled by the injured claimant, it is referred to as self-administration and when performed by a company like Medivest Benefit Advisors, Inc., it is known as professional administration.

With a federal law on the books prohibiting premature billing of future medicals to Medicare and the potential for those not complying with the MSP being denied Medicare benefits for the claimed/released injury, is it wise to allow injured parties to manage and administer post settlement future medicals? The National Council on Compensation Insurance, Inc. (NCCI) recently published a research brief updating its 2014 study on Workers’ Compensation MSAs (WCMSAs) and WCMSA reviews and reported that between 2010 and 2015, approximately 98% of all WCMSAs from the study’s 11,000 MSA data sample were self-administered. That seems outrageous when injured parties are notorious for quickly spending money received from lump-sum settlements. Statistics in a personal injury practice guide by The Rutter Group indicate that somewhere between 25 and 30% of accident victims spend all settlement money within two months of receiving the funds and that up to 90% of accident victims use all settlement proceeds within five years.[3] Spending sprees seem common with lottery winners, some professional athletes, and most likely other people that come into money quickly. Congress considered the poor spending habits of settlement recipients when it enacted the Periodic Payment Settlement Act of 1982 (PPSA)[4],[5], and in subsequent related legislation.[5] Because annuity payments paid under the PPSA are paid tax-free and injured parties can often be irresponsible with their spending when they receive lump-sum settlements, structured settlements are often a wise choice to help injured parties preserve settlement funds for their needs.

Irresponsible spending of settlement funds by injured parties is sad, but when settlement funds are misspent by people other than the injured parties, it can be tragic. A Wall Street Journal article recently highlighted this risk.[7] In 1980, Nicole Herivaux lost the use of one of her arms due to alleged medical malpractice at the time of her birth in New York. In 1983, the minor’s family settled a malpractice lawsuit in exchange for a structured settlement that paid monthly annuity payments and a few hundred thousand dollars in lump sum money that could be used for Nicole’s education, among other things. The company that started making settlement payments initially deposited the annuity checks in Nicole’s mother’s name, “as guardian” of Nicole directly into a bank account. That company later transferred the responsibility for making those payments to a different insurance company in 1995, when Nicole was 15 and still a minor. Nicole Herivaux is now an adult with student loan debt and alleged in a 2018 lawsuit that the new company sent the annuity payments directly to her mother without any payment restriction or oversight and that her mother misused and inappropriately exhausted Nicole’s settlement funds. If the settlement had included professional administration of a custodial account, money intended for the minor could have paid off Nicole’s education expenses and provided her a better chance to live with peace of mind, dignity and security.

The Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS), the regulatory body running the Medicare program and charged with the responsibility of interpreting the MSP has promulgated regulations and issued memos helpful to determining reasonable and appropriate measures to comply with the MSP. A 2011 memo from CMS’s Regional Office in Dallas from Sally Stalcup, as MSP Regional Coordinator, announced that Medicare Set-Aside is CMS’s “method of choice and the agency feels it provides the best protection for the program and the Medicare beneficiary.”[8] From the context of the Stalcup memo, it is clear the use of the term “Set-aside” included a MSA arrangement described above, and that Set-asides (MSAs) would apply in both workers’ compensation and liability cases. The Stalcup Memo also announced that “each attorney is going to have to decide, based on the specific facts of each of their cases, whether or not there is funding for future medicals and if so, a need to protect the Trust Funds.”

However, it is one thing to set money aside for the intended purpose and quite another to properly administer the money. Even when an injured claimant hires an attorney to represent them to obtain a settlement, judgment or award (“settlement”), settlement funds reserved for future medicals can be misspent. For example, attorney misconduct was found in a South Carolina Bar disciplinary case where an attorney representing a claimant failed to properly administer funds set aside to protect Medicare’s interests (MSA funds) as a secondary payer for future medicals.[9] In another bar disciplinary case, an Illinois licensed attorney used trust funds for improper purposes when the trust funds were to be maintained in trust until it was determined whether they belonged to the attorney’s client or Medicare.[10]

Did the attorneys in these matters know how to report settlements to CMS’ Benefits Coordination & Recovery Center (BCRC) contractor, how to request Medicare conditional payment amounts, perform bill review and potentially dispute and finalize conditional payment lien amounts? Did they consider whether their client’s injury and/or financial condition might lend itself to a conditional payment lien compromise or waiver request? Furthermore, did the attorneys know how to properly administer the MSA funds that were set aside for their clients’ future medicals? If the attorneys had sought the advice of a competent company that performs these functions regularly, they would have been in a better position to protect their clients, protect the Medicare Trust Funds and protect their professional standing.

Allowing incompetent, injured claimants to self-administer their own MSA accounts cannot be a prudent way to protect Medicare’s interests in preserving the nation’s Medicare Trust Funds. Even competent claimants likely experience difficulties attempting to self-administer MSA funds. While CMS makes resources available to individuals intending to self-administer an MSA account including a WCMSA Reference Guide and a Self-Administration Tool Kit, but what percentage of injured claimants will read and follow the protocol of the 127-page WCMSA Reference Guide and the 31-page Self-Administration Tool Kit?

Self-administration is surely harder than filing a standard federal income tax return. Plenty of people find it helpful to use professional assistance or digital software to help them file their tax return. [11] A self-administering claimant needs to evaluate bills for medical items and expenses, including prescription drug expenses, to verify that they are both injury-related, Medicare allowable and otherwise reimbursable. Once bills are reviewed, a decision still needs to be made as to how much should be paid. Is the provider a Medicare-approved provider? Should the amount be the Medicare allowable rate, the provider’s bill rate or the usual and customary rate? Is there a Group Health Insurance plan involved? Does it matter if the case stems from a liability case versus a workers’ compensation claim? Does the Code of Federal Regulations say anything about these distinctions? Does CMS provide guidance in this area via its website, its Medicare Learning Network, or WCMSA Reference Guide? Have there been any cases evaluating these issues and was the claimant’s injury in a jurisdiction where case law might affect the amount of money to be set aside for those future medicals? Will a claimant be able to keep records on their own sufficient to withstand CMS scrutiny to determine whether MSA account spending is MSP compliant? Will the claimant remember to prepare and transmit required annual attestations of MSP accounting compliance? Because the answer to these questions is only part of the MSP compliance puzzle, it is little surprise that CMS announced professional administration as recommended for MSA fund administration. In addition to providing a full array of Professional Administration services, Medivest also offers a Self-Administration Kit service that provides customer service and claims support as well as discounts on durable medical equipment and prescription medication to help competent claimants take on self-administration.

[1] 42 U.S.C. § 1395y(b).

[2] The Rutter Group, “California Practice Guide: Personal Injury” Chapter 4.

[3] Re: Section 130 Qualified Assignments, 2003 WL 22662008, at *3 (legislative history to the PPSA detailed that additions to the law helped provide certainty that periodic payments of personal injury damages are excluded from the gross income of the recipient. S. Rep. No. 97-646, 97^th Cong., 2d Sess. 4 (1982)).

[4] Periodic Payment Settlement Act of 1982 (PL 97–473 (HR 5470), PL 97–473, January 14, 1983, 96 Stat 2605) (through tax benefits, the PPSA encourages use of structured settlements to resolve personal physical injury and physical sickness cases).

[5] Re: Section 130 Qualified Assignments, 2003 WL 22662008, at *18 (The public policy encouraging use of structured settlements by providing a tax subsidy was affirmed in JCX-15-99, the Joint Committee on Taxation, Tax Treatment of Structured Settlement Arrangements from March 16, 1999 (pointing out perils of lump sum settlements when “. . . the individual may, by design or poor luck, mismanage his or her funds so that future medical expenses are not met.” JCX 15-99 accompanied H.R. 263, “The Structured Settlement Protection Act,” 106^th Cong., 1^st Sess. Section 5891 of the Code enacted by a subsequent version of that bill, H.R. 2884, on January 23, 2002).

[6] Under Section 104(a) of the Internal Revenue Code (I.R.C.), personal injury settlement proceeds are tax-free, but when paid in a lump sum, any investment earnings or interest paid on those funds as they grow over time is taxable. Pursuant to Section 104(a)(2) of the I.R.C., each structured settlement payment over the entire period of payment of the annuity stream is tax-free to the victim. The details of taxable consequences associated with interest gained after receipt of each annuity should be evaluated with a licensed tax professional in conjunction with a structured settlement advisor.

[7] Leslie Scism, Lawsuit Alleges MetLife Mistake Helped a Woman Keep Settlement Money From Her Daughter Insurer faces lawsuit over structured-settlement annuity related to old business, WALL STREET JOURNAL., February 21, 2018.

[8] Sally Stalcup, MSP Regional Coordinator, Region VI (May 25, 2011, Handout).

[9] In the Matter of Morris, 343 S.C. 651, 653-54, 541 S.E.2d 844, 845 (2001).

[10] In the Matter of: Charles Augustus Boyle, Attorney-Respondent, No. 268739, 2014 WL 10505032, at *2. (Attorney voluntarily relinquished his license to practice law after an investigation revealed among other misconduct, that he failed to pay his client’s medical bills from settlement proceeds in one case, failed to deposit settlement proceeds into a guardianship account established on behalf of a minor in another case, failed to notify Medicare that four other cases settled and failed to pay the Medicare conditional payment liens for those four cases).

[11] Excluding those individuals who responded “none of the above” to the question of how they file their taxes, gobankingrates.com reports from an internet poll that of just over 5,000 people, 36.8% said they use either an accountant (28.5%) or a brick and mortar tax company like H&R Block (8.3%) and 34.5% responded that they use tax filing software.

What the WCMSA Reference Guide states:

MSA funds must be placed in an interest-bearing account that is separate from the individual’s personal savings and checking accounts.

The interest must be deposited into the MSA account to be used for MSA-covered expenses.

You can use the MSA account to pay for the income tax on the interest income.

For further clarification regarding how the individual can pay for the taxes from the interest incomed earned in their account, refer to the CMS Memo Dated July 11, 2005, Subject: Medicare Secondary Payer (MPS) – Workers’ Compensation (WC) Additional Frequency Asked Questions.

“Q6. Treatment of Taxable Interest Income Earned on a WCMSA – If I receive a Form 1099-INT for the interest income earned on my WCMSA account, may I charge the income tax on that amount against the WCMSA?

How Medivest Handles the 1099-INT:

Medivest will advise the Member to prepare his/her tax return two ways to determine the increased income tax burden, if any:

Include the MSA interest income in the income tax return

Exclude the MSA interest income in the income tax return

Answers to Common Questions

Question 1. If I am taxed on the earned interest, why can’t I have it?

Answer 1. CMS’ guidelines state that Medicare Set-Aside funds place must be placed into an interest-bearing account and are to be used for covered medical expenses.

Question 2. Why do I have to report the earned interest to the IRS?

Answer 2. Per IRS guidelines, all interest income is taxable, unless specifically excluded.

Question 3. Isn’t my injury settlement tax-exempt?

Answer 3. Any compensation you receive from a settlement because of physical injuries or sickness is not taxable. However, the interest earned after the settlement occurs is taxable.

Best Practices

Helpful Self-Administration Tips:

Set Up your MSA Correctly

Learn the Process and Develop Good Habits Now

Know What Expenses Your MSA Covers

What to Do When Your MSA is Exhausted or Depleted

What Happens it Self-Administering is Too Difficult?

What is Self-Administration?

What is Professional Administration?

Two Ways to Fund Your MSA Account

Before the settlement has occurred, the settling parties will discuss the ways a MSA account can be funded. Typically, there are two options:

Lump-Sum – a single lump sum payment to fund your MSA account.

Establishing a Self-Administration Bank Account

Below is a list of CMS’ requirements regarding opening up a separate bank account for the MSA funds.

Deposit MSA funds into its own account, separate from any other accounts you may have

The account must earn interest and the interest must stay in the account

The account should be insured by Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (FDIC)

Choose a bank or an account that does not charge fees if you have a low balance

Select an account that allows you to write checks

Know What Is Covered

It is important to recognize that not every medical bill or service can be paid out of the MSA account. For individuals self-administering their account, it is highly important to be aware of qualified expenses. Below is a partial list of the expenses that can and cannot be paid out of the account:

Expenses That Can Be Paid

Funds can only be used to pay for future care that is Medicare covered and related to your injury.

Cost of copying documents

Mailing fees/postage

Any banking fees related to the account

Paying income tax on the interest income earned in the account*

*Note – The MSA funds are not considered taxable income, but the interest earned is taxable. Each year your bank will issue an IRS 1099-INT form for the interest earned in the account.

Expenses That Cannot Be Paid

Fees for trustees, custodians, or other professionals hired to help administer the account

Expenses for administration of the MSA other than those listed above

Attorney costs for establishing the MSA

Cannot use to purchase a Medicare supplemental insurance policy or a Medigap policy

Medicare premiums, co-payments, and deductibles

Acupuncture

Routine dental care

Eyeglasses

Hearing aides

For a more extensive list of what Medicare will pay, click here to obtain a copy of the free handbook “Medicare & You”.

Keep Accurate Records of All Transactions

Transaction date

Check number

“Payable to” or provider’s name

Date of service

Description – procedure, service or item received, deposit, interest, other allowable expenses

Amount paid

Deposit amount

Account balance

Interest earned

What is Coordination of Benefits for a MSA?

What is the MSA Attestation?

Total spent for medical services

Total spent for prescription drugs

Grand total of expenditures

Total of interest income the account earned if any

Balance of MSA account at the end of the calendar year

Annual Attestation or Expenditure Letters Reporting

Annual Attestations must be submitted every year, no later than 30 days after the end of each reporting period (beginning one year from the date of establishment of the MSA account). Annual attestations should continue through final exhaustion of the account.

Temporary Exhaustion occurs when the MSA account funds have exhausted before the next annuity has been deposited into the account.

Final Depletion or Permanent Exhaustion is where the MSA account has no money left and no future deposits of funds are expected.

Death Occurs / Inheritance before the MSA account is permanently exhausted you will need to notify the BCRC of death. This may require the MSA account to stay open for some time to pay outstanding claims.

Completely Exhausted within 60 days of the date the MSA account is depleted, send the BCRC a final attestation that the account is ‘Completely Exhausted”.

Loses Medicare Entitlement